Embedded Files
Post date: Dec 25, 2011 1:04:12 PM
There are a number of ways to improve the disc brake on a Commando.
1) Fit a 1/2" mastercylinder from another brand of bike.
2) Buy an aftermarket Lockheed or similar calliper and/or disc.
3) Sleeve your mastercylinder to 1/2".
4) Get a 11mm conversion from the US or a 1/2" sleeve job from the UK (See the bottom of the page)
I would recommend Vintage Brake in the US for interesting info, on drum brakes as well.
An approach to 3) follows.....
I need to make a point regarding liability. I am not an engineer. I have no qualifications or experience of engineering. If you are interested in following this modification you must get it checked by a qualified engineer who can certify that it is safe. Do not do it otherwise.
I need to make a point regarding liability. I am not an engineer. I have no qualifications or experience of engineering. If you are interested in following this modification you must get it checked by a qualified engineer who can certify that it is safe. Do not do it otherwise.
A number of people have been been in touch with me over the last couple of years in regard to the master cylinder brake modification sleeving it to 1/2 inch as detailed in Classic Motorcycle Mechanics.
Here follows the simple version...
The original Lockheed master cylinder as fitted to Norton Commandos from 1972 (and to some Ducatis) was given a 5/8 bore for reasons which only promote cynicism and do not bear repeating here. The end result was the brake did not work very well. The lever felt very wooden, and it was hard to get enough braking from it.
I decided to try and improve the hydraulic advantage by sleeving the master cylinder down. I had experienced good results with a 1/2 inch Grimeca cylinder on a Norton so took that size as a reasonable objective.
Having heard of seals from a 1980s Kawasaki GPZ 500 (EZ500 in some countries) being used for the this purpose I took that as a starting point. I obtained a M/C from one and drew up a piston which had the shape and width of the Kawasaki piston but otherwise the length of the Norton.
Click for larger image
My master cylinder was sleeved in stainless steel. If using SS, and I would recommend it, the piston should be made from something hard but not SS. I recommend Aluminium Bronze 3. (As a friend said, AB3 will still be there when the Vogons invade Earth) Do not use soft alloys. While they may stand up to the wear inside the cylinder they will pickup and smear at the contact point with the lever. There is no reason why the cylinder could not be sleeved in aluminium just as original, and the piston made in steel. But if you think about it those materials were chosen for poor reasons and we can do better. Why put steel in a rust prone environment?
Click for larger printable image of piston design
The piston is a fairly straightforward turning job. The Kawasaki seal kit number is 43020-1098. This may be an Australian part number, it's from a GPZ 500 from early eighties, single disc type. In the US this bike was called an EZ 500.
In the kit you get a piston, seals and spring. Biff the piston and use the seals and spring. If you need a new boot and spring clip they are available from the usual sources of Norton parts.
The original cylinder had a trap valve in the same end of the bore to slow the fluid in the downward direction (ask yourself, why would anyone make the brake slow to act? No, don't. ) Leave this out. It wouldn't fit the smaller bore anyway. With this exception, assembling the brake is exactly as for the standard setup. If anything about your setup is not standard, for example the calliper, or the lever (any change to the lever is significant, mail me if you need to know why), deep thought may be needed.
While I have not struck problems in those I have assembled personally or heard of any problems with the many assembled to these instructions elsewhere there is need to be cautious . There are variations to dimensions in the original casting, for example I am told there is up to 160 thou difference possible in length of the internal bore. When you assemble your brake, before you fill and bleed it, make sure the lever can travel right to the bar.
Mine has now done in excess of 20,000 miles, most in tough city traffic. It gets a lot of hard use. I dissassembled it recently because the boot had ripped (it was not renewed when I did the sleeve job) and I could find no evidence of wear anywhere.
The all up price in Australia is about A$90 for sleeving, $45 piston, $49 seal kit, a total of less than A$200. About $100US. Cheap for a good brake. If you are having problems getting your cylinder sleeved a number of people from around the world have sent their's to the person who did mine in Sydney. One bloke in the UK got his back in 18 days.The outfit which does the sleeving does many brake cylinders every day.
Partmasters
attention Terry Milligan
18 Harp St,
Belmore
NSW 2192
Australia,
ph 02 9787 3111
He takes the usual credit cards. I don't mind calling him for you to let him know you want to send one.
Pistons can be made by...
Alan Graham,
Po Box 92,
Douglas Park
NSW 2569
Australia
(Ph 0246 32 7202)
I don't know whether Alan would want to do business worldwide. I have no financial interest in these businesses.
Installation instructions
While soaking the seals in brake fluid inspect the piston to see there are no sharp corners that will cut the seals. Put the seals on carefully, the main trap is letting the rear one fall into the groove for the boot. It is hard to get out. I nurse the seals on with a tiny screwdriver without sharp edges.
Put the boot on the piston in the same way it goes on the original. Lubricate the cylinder with fluid and carefully insert the piston, careful with the seals. Before pushing against the spring arrange the boot and its spring clip in the right place, then push the piston down with your thumb and prod the boot and spring clip down into place with a screwdriver. It pays to start the clip by pushing one side down first so it does not get caught in the slots for the screws that hold the M/C to the switchgear.
Holding the piston down in place (don't let it pop out, the less you have to put the seals in and out of the entrance to the cylinder, the better), put the lever in and let it take the place of your thumb, and then holding the lever against the pressure of the spring, slip the bolt into the pivot. Pop a tiny amount of grease on the end of the piston and you are done...
The modification was printed in Classic Bike Mechanics Oct 1998. The article included an interesting (and compelling) before and after comparison test as follows...
The best way to describe the end result of the modification is to talk about reduced lever pressure. It takes less lever pressure to achieve the same braking affect. The graph is a good illustration of this.
I would recommend the change to a nylon stainless braided line at the same time. If anything promotes feel it is not having what is essentially a balloon attached to your brake. The increased fluid pressure with the modification means even more balloon effect if using a rubber line.
I need to stress that the specs on this page are for a standard calliper setup only. If you have a non standard calliper with a larger piston size, or if you have a twin disc setup, the lever would need to pump more fluid to operate the brakes. The question then becomes, can it pump the fluid needed before the lever hits the bar? I'm not saying it can't be done, but you are on your own at that point. Before I proceeded with the above conversion I was worried about this as a possibility even with the standard calliper setup and had thought about shifting the primary feed hole in the reservoir to compensate if it proved to be the case. There was plenty of room as it transpired. I was cheered by a simple measurement. The standard setup needs about 9mm of piston travel to operate the brake. Wth the square area of the piston being reduced by a factor of 1 in 3, the piston travel with a 1/2" piston would have to be about 14mm, and there was more than 20mm travel available between the primary and secondary holes in the reservoir. When you have assembled the cylinder hold it up against a handlebar and pull the lever in. Make sure there is no impediment to the lever coming right back in.
When I first did the modification I made much of the ability to lock the front wheel (do not do this at home..!) with the new brake. Subsequently I have realised I was tricking the front into locking up. If you suddenly pull the brake on you have less of the tyre on the ground than if you squeeze it slowly.
When you squeeze it slowly you force the tyre down on the road more firmly, increasing the contact area. I feel confident the brake will still lock the front when applied this way but either I have become more wise since the first flush or I no longer have the bottle for full speed tests.
December 2001... I am working on a 11mm conversion. Stay tuned. Also Stan Smith of Rocky Point Cycle can create a 11mm Magura with appropriate switchgear for a Norton Commando. And RGM will now do a 1/2" conversion similar to the above for a relatively low cost by mail order. I have not seen one so cannot endorse it.
Chris Ghent
cghent@tpg.com.au
Postscript
Postscript
An alternative is to send your master cylinder directly to:
Central West Brake & Clutch
PO Box 1385
Orange NSW 2800
Ph: (02) 6362-4077
but phone ahead first
Also Justin at Halray Brake Reconditioning in Lismore NSW adds this
" I have read the article on your web site in relation to the modification of the Norton brake master cylinder. Over the years we have made a similar modification to this cylinder.It first came to my attention about 15 years ago when I was presented at my workshop front counter with a sleeve kit that a guy had purchase over the internet containing an alloy sleeve(knurled on the outside diameter), piston & seals along with instructions on how to fit. I was more than happy to utilise his piston & seals but insisted that we prepare & fit our own stainless steel sleeve. We have since produced a nmber of the sleeves,pistons & seals as required, in which we now have CNC machining facilities to produce these. Perhaps we can assist with any modifications that is needed with your club. Halray Brake Reconditioning is a business that has been sleeving since the late sixties & is recognised as one of Australia's leading sleeving & brake rebuilding companies.
Thought we may be able to assist, please feel free to contact justin@halraybrake.com.au."
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse